Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Distrct 5 town Hall October 4 2025

 


Benedictine auditorium



At an October 4 meeting held on the beautiful campus of Benedictine Schools on River Road, District 5 Supervisor Jonathan Lyle, School Board Member Ellen Robinson, and Planning Commissioner Martin Dean shared information on a wide range of topics about Goochland other than data centers. Supervisors Neil Spoonhower, District 2, and Tom Winfree, District 3, were also there.

The attendance was not as robust as community meetings held at the high school, perhaps because the meeting was livestreamed, enabling people to watch the meeting and football games simultaneously. One unsilenced cell phone in the audience blared football theme music.

Kudos to Director of Information Technology Dan Stowers and his team for making the presentation accessible in real time and archived on the county website at https://goochlandcova.portal.civicclerk.com/event/4502/media . The meeting lasted for a bit more than three hours. Following are some highlights. Please take time to watch the meeting, the video includes closed captioning.

Lyle explained that the session was designed to share brief sketches of “nuts and bolts” of county operations.

Robinson said that Goochland Schools “are preparing out children for the future while giving them the strongest foundation possible.” She championed the reintroduction of cursive writing to elementary classrooms, which helps students hone fine motor skills, and the sensory input of placing pen to paper also helps increase information retention and critical thinking. Goochland Schools, said Robinson, are well aware of the challenges of technology and are exploring ways for tech to enhance rather than distract from the educational experience.

“I personally feel we should teach at the appropriate level how to use AI. We also teach how to think independently without those tools. How to read a physical book, be a critical thinker. Sit with a difficult problem, communicate ideas clearly, write, research question, analyze and defend their conclusions, the importance of the human brain and its capacity to learn through doing.” The ultimate goal is to make Goochland graduates tech savvy responsible digital citizens.

Dr. Jennifer Waggener, GCPS assistant superintendent for administration, shared additional information about our schools, which, she contended, measure up well against the private school option. Of last June’s graduating class of 250, 97 earned an associate’s degree from Reynolds Community College before they received their high school diploma. Goochland’s Marine Corps Junior ROTC program is the largest in the region and regularly places well in competitions.

Our career and technical education department offers a wide array of options for students to explore future careers. Ground is expected to be broken next year for a CTE addition to the high school to expand the program. (Go to https://www.goochlandschools.org/ to https:

Waggener explained the Golden Bulldog pass program where Goochland citizens 60 or older can get free admission to home games and ticket discounts for theatrical performances. Go to https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScKCSqXPxWO75nH8tvsvw3-DdXF8K6BZPmKVx2gHTm4xsTlIg/viewform  for details.

 

She invited everyone to attend the upcoming production by the Drama Department, “The Play that goes wrong” on October 16, 17, and 18. These plays are outstanding and deserve to have every seat filled at every performance. Go to https://sites.google.com/glnd.k12.va.us/goochland-drama-dept/2025-2026-season/oklahoma?authuser=0 for details and to buy tickets.

To follow and support our Bulldog athletes in action, Go to https://www.ghsbulldogsathletics.com/schedule?year=2026-2027 .

Lyle then plunged into fiscal matters, contending that land use and the county budget are the two most important tasks of supervisors.  The “big four” he concentrates on are public safety, education, roads, and free and fair elections. Once those budgetary needs have been addressed properly, he will consider other things.

He rebutted the refrain of “build houses not data centers” by explaining that a home consumes $1.25 in services for every dollar of tax revenue it generates. “Houses do not pay the bills,” said Lyle. The current tax rate of 53 cents per $100 on assessed valuation has been in place for 20 years, but tax bills have increased due to rising assessments. Real estate taxes contribute about 73 percent of the budget.

The county is in the process of retaining experts to address water issues that plague some homes in the Tuckahoe Creek Service District, especially Parkside Village and Mosaic. A vendor for this has been selected and the supervisors are expected to approve the contract for this at their November meeting. 

Lyle said that the supervisors determine the level of service citizens want, things like fire-rescue stations, excellence in schools and so forth. Financing the difference can be done by bond issues, which increases the county’s indebtedness. He delved into the near-term capital needs, fire-rescue stations, the new courthouse, the CTE addition for the high school, and whether it would be prudent for the county to borrow more. Lyle believes that any added bond issuance should be approved by a referendum, like one that was overwhelmingly approved in 2021.

Lyle repeated his commitment to commercial growth in Goochland, especially West Creek. He explained that securing significant investments like the Eli Lilly facility is a long and complicated process.  Non-disclosure agreements (NDAs) are an integral part of attracting business to a locality, said Lyle. When he served on the Henrico Industrial Development Authority in the 1980s, he learned how these work.

“They (NDAs) are used by companies who are exploring a decision. They haven't made a decision. And so, there's a very real reason they don't necessarily want to go out on the front page of The Wall Street Journal and say, hey, we're thinking of coming to Goochland County. And so other companies can say, well, maybe we should buy that land. Other people will say, oh, well, they're interested in it. Maybe the land price just went up $50,000 an acre. There are a lot of reasons why you want to have a conversation without saying this is a done deal. The other is that the market. Somebody says, oh, well, they're going to build a $5 billion plant in Goochland County. What's that going to do to their debt on their balance sheet? Is that going to affect their stock price? I don't do the market, but I understand you can short stock or long stock. And so, they start making plays out there based on public information on decisions that haven't yet been made.”

Lyle acknowledged that NDAs create a trust issue and explained that going forward new protocols require that supervisors will have the final say on if and when NDAs are used.

Economic development is working t grow Goochland’s commercial tax base toward a 30 percent commercial/70 percent residential ratio. It is occurring in places where the county has long desired this to occur.

Lyle touted the power of networking and asked anyone who has connections with companies who are considering expansion to recommend Goochland as a destination and contact Raley to get the ball rolling.

Dean, who is also a volunteer fire captain at Manakin Company 1, attempted to “turn down the heat” around land use matters by helping people better understand the system that operated to make sure that optimal decisions are made.

He began by explaining our system of government and comparing it to ancient Athens, the cradle of democracy. Pure democracy, where every citizen weighs in on every decision every day, a full-time job. Our founding fathers believed that a pure democracy was not a practical way to govern and build a representative democracy instead. Now we vote for representatives to “make tough calls on our behalf.”

Virginia is a Dillon Rule state, which means that localities have only those powers specifically given to them by the General Assembly. “There are a lot of things in this county that we would love to regulate, but we can’t because the state is not giving us that authority.” These include air, land water, and where power lines go.

At sone point all land went through some kind of public process. Land use decisions do not set precedent. Each parcel is unique, which is why public input in the process is so important. The county has little control over the timing of a process. All landowners have rights, including the right to a timely hearing.

When an application is on the planning commission docket, that board has 70 days to make a recommendation to the supervisors. The supervisors can slow the process down, and the applicant can slow it further.

Most of the details on a land use change are worked out after the approval during the plan of development process. This is done according to many codes.

This is a process during which many things change by design to improve an application. The process is proven and works even though the outcome may not please everyone.

Spoonhower thanked everyone for attending and their engagement. He said that going forward, following citizen comment, supervisors will have the opportunity to address those comments. “It is frustrating to hear people spouting all kinds of things that just aren’t true without giving us the opportunity to react. “

 Spoonhower said that he did not vote for a data center but rather for a technology overlay district to give more protection to Readers Branch. “I voted to add requirements for data centers that are already by right. I will support the right data center. I have no concerns about 55 + community but do have specific concerns about this (Tract) proposal.”

He cares that data centers cannot be seen heard, smelled, or have an impact on people’s lives. Spoonhower said he has not seen a final plan that indicates the number, size, or location of specific data centers.

“I’m not going to vote for anything that will disturb your lives. This has to be the best damn project in the country. That’s what I’m voting for,” said Spoonhower. His remarks were greeted with applause. Go to the about 2:25 minute mark on the recording to listen.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 


No comments: